Find My Work!

The Columbus Crew finished with yet another draw on Saturday, this time against the Portland Timbers. Portland struck first early in the match on a slow rolling shot that snuck its way past Patrick Schulte. The Black & Gold evened the game courtesy of a Cucho Hernandez shot that found the bottom corner in the second half. The Timbers equalized a mere six minutes later, capitalizing off a defensive mistake by Rudy Camacho. A Steven Moreira screamer from outside the box leveled the game again for Columbus, but a Cucho free kick bounced off the inside of the woodwork and did not cross the line to end the game in dramatic fashion. The Crew started its usual first-choice lineup but made a few minor tweaks in shape before and during the game. Let’s dive into the tactical decisions that went into yet another Columbus draw. Aggression as a double-edged sword Teams around Major League Soccer know that the Black & Gold like to play a high-pressure and possession style of soccer. This tactical choice means that the Crew likes to aggressively gamble, whether trying to win the ball back or committing numbers forward in the attack. Against Portland, the pros and cons of this aggressive style reared its head. First, let’s start with what went wrong for Columbus. The most obvious example is the Timbers’ second goal of the game. The ball was played into the feet of Evander, which made Camacho step up on him to try and knock the ball out. The French center back often does this whenever the player he is marking is receiving the ball. Camacho’s pressure pulled him out of position, allowing Evander to dummy the ball and let the pass slip behind himself and Camacho. Subsequently, Camacho ran into his running mate Moreira, taking them both out of the play entirely. From there, Portland went on to score against an undermanned and scrambling Columbus defense. Many would say this is bad defense, but it is simply the risk Wilfried Nancy, and the Crew accepted when they signed onto playing this high-pressure system. Almost always, Camacho wins the ball, and the Crew can start a counterattack of his defensive quality. In this instance though, Evander’s trickiness caused the veteran defender to misjudge the pass and it ended up with the ball in the back of the net. On the other end though, the Black & Gold’s aggression paid off in a big way. Columbus’ ability to commit the outside center backs into the attack worked when Moreira hit a stunner from outside the box to tie the game. Throughout the match and especially when the Crew were trailing, Moreira and Malte Amundsen would step into the midfield. This gave the Black & Gold more width and attacking options in the final third. On Moreira’s goal, the ball was switched from the left side to him on the right side, where he was able to take one touch and have a shot. It was a laser to the top corner that would be hard to replicate, but Columbus will not complain. Moreira’s goal would not have been possible if the Crew had not gambled and pushed the center backs into the attack. While Camacho’s aggression on the defensive end cost the Black & Gold, Moreira’s aggression to go forward favored Columbus. Often, the aggressive decisions are going to favor the Crew as this team meshes more throughout the season. Formation changes The Crew came into this game set up in the usual 5-2-3 formation, but it had a twist. Yaw Yeboah did not line up in his left wingback spot, instead, Will Sands occupied that space. Yeboah played in the attack with Diego Rossi and Hernandez but tucked inside more rather than playing on the wing. By coming infield, Yeboah let Sands have more space outside to overlap and get into the attack. Crew fans will notice that despite this tweak, the Black & Gold did not have much success attacking in the first half. Portland adjusted well to Columbus’ formation change and made it hard to play down the left side. One of the Timbers’ defensive midfielders would manmark Sands on the left wing, forming a five-back formation for Portland. With Sands and Yeboah covered by the dropping midfielder and outside back, they did not get the ball much in a controlled buildup. This tactical adjustment by Portland gave the Crew fits and allowed the visitors to build a lead. In the second half, Nancy changed things up to prevent this roadblock. Sands was substituted for Jacen Russell-Rowe, who slid into the attack to form a more fluid front three. Now Yeboah moved into his more natural wingback position while Rossi, Hernandez, and Russell-Rowe roamed the attacking third. This allowed Columbus more attacking firepower in the attack, while also gaining a player in Russell-Rowe who can combine in close quarters with the other attackers. Portland’s defense emphasized plugging as many attacking lanes as possible to suffocate the Crew’s attack. The only way through was by whipping crosses in, or quickly combining in tight spaces. This meant the Black & Gold had to commit more bodies forward, shifting into a 1-4-5 on offense to put Portland under an immense amount of pressure. It worked, resulting in Columbus’ first goal. With Aidan Morris, Mo Farsi, Moreira, and Rossi overloading the Timbers’ defense on the left, they combined around the defense and ultimately found Hernandez on a late-arriving run for the goal. The in-game adjustment to bring on Russell-Rowe in place of Sands ended up being a huge move to get the Crew back in the game. It was important for the Black & Gold to recognize their plan was not working and adjust as fast as they could. They did, and it got them a point when the final whistle blew.

The Columbus Crew returned to MLS play on Saturday evening, taking on Real Salt Lake away from home. The Black & Gold’s lineup was heavily rotated, featuring only three regular starters such as Aidan Morris, Rudy Camacho, and Malte Amundsen. Columbus still played its brand of soccer but had to rely more on their defense against an RSL squad that sent out their first team. It was a back-and-forth contest, but it ended up goalless. Coming away with a point on the road with a heavily rotated squad will be seen as a win in Wilfried Nancy’s eyes. Nancy still set his team up the same way but made some tweaks based on the personnel on the pitch. Let’s dive into those tactical changes that allowed the Crew to grab a point on the road. Altered formation to accommodate the squad’s playstyles When the lineups were released, the biggest question was the formation the Black & Gold would line up in. Players like Sean Zawadzki, Max Arfsten, Alex Matan, and Taha Habroune can all play multiple positions, so Nancy could have gone several different ways regarding the formation. He opted to keep the defensive and pressing formation the same as usual with a 5-2-3. On offense though, the Black & Gold set themselves in a 3-2-2-3 with a boxed midfield. The three center backs remained in their positions, although Phillip Quinton and Amundsen were free to go forward into the midfield if they wanted. Morris and Zawadzki were the two defensive midfielders, mostly staying in the center of the pitch as opposed to shifting outside like the midfielders did against Tigres. Matan and Habroune were in front of Morris and Zawadzki as dueling no. 10s. They remained in the advance attacking positions but were free to drop deeper if the space was there. Will Sands and Arfsten pushed up from their wingback positions to be wingers while Jacen Russell-Rowe took a central striker role. That was the base formation the Black & Gold were in, but like any Nancy team, it is subject to change as the game progresses. One thing that changed was the number of players committed to the defensive midfield area. Both Morris and Zawadzki stayed in that area, but an outside centerback would step up as well based on where the ball was. If the ball was possessed on one of the wings, the backside centerback would step into the midfield to help aid in switching the ball. The other outside center back would be support for the player in possession on that side. Another thing the Crew liked to do at times was push Matan and Habroune up to form a front five. The two midfielders would slide in alongside Russell-Rowe and give an extra punch to the attack. This move did not yield many fruitful results, but it was interesting to see them try to go after the win. These changes did not net Columbus three points, but it allowed them to keep pressure on the RSL backline and come out with a draw. Columbus’ press The Crew kept their normal press going against Real Salt Lake, despite featuring a heavily rotated squad. Working out of a 5-2-3, the Black & Gold tried their best to create chaos and create turnovers that they could translate into attacking chances. The front three consisting of Russell-Rowe, Matan, and Habroune would press the opposing defenders and try to contain them. Their job was not to allow the center backs to advance the ball through the center by getting beat off the dribble. Behind them, Morris and Zawadzki stepped up to try and cut off the splits. Dropping midfielders tried to come back towards the defense to gain a numbers advantage, but Columbus’ dueling defensive midfielders followed them to ramp up the pressure. On the outsides, the wingbacks’ job was to press high on RSL’s outside backs. If they could contain the outside while Morris and Zawadzki covered the splits, they could bottleneck the hosts. With all the other players pushing up, the center backs for the Black & Gold would as well. This shortened the field for RSL, but it also left the Crew vulnerable in behind. With both wingbacks committed to the press, the wide areas were only covered by the outside center backs. This allowed long balls over the top to expose the backline and give the hosts lots of quality looks on goal. With quick players like Diego Luna and Chicho Arango up top, it posed a mismatch for Columbus’ defense. Luckily for the Black & Gold, none of RSL’s attacks resulted in a goal. Nobody ever roots for a game to end in a draw, but the Crew and Nancy will take the point and move on to the next game.

The Columbus Crew advanced in dramatic fashion in the CONCACAF Champions Cup, besting Tigres on penalties. The game got off to a disastrous start for the Black & Gold, with a failed pull-back by Patrick Schulte resulting in an easy opener for the hosts. From there, Columbus had to scrap and claw to generate scoring chances. Ultimately, the Crew found their goal in the second half courtesy of Diego Rossi. The 1-1 score line remained the same for the rest of regulation and overtime, setting the stage for a penalty shootout. Schulte redeemed himself in a big way, saving two Tigres penalties to allow the Black & Gold to advance 4-3 in the shootout. Wilfried Nancy did not change philosophy much against the Mexican giants but instead allowed his team to trust their process and figure out a way to win. Let’s dive into the tactics that allowed Columbus to advance to the semi-finals. First half woes The first half could not have started worse for the Black & Gold. Only three minutes into the game, a gaffe by Schulte gifted Tigres the lead and made life even more difficult for the Crew. In response to this, Columbus did not change the way they played. They continued to go forward and defend like they were doing before the goal went in, showing a strict belief in the game plan Nancy had set in place. Despite the resiliency to stick to the tactical vision, the Black & Gold struggled in the first 45 minutes. Tigres’ pressure caused the Crew to turn the ball over in dangerous positions. The hosts even had two more goals overturned due to offsides or fouls, but Columbus got lucky to only concede one. The Tigres press was designed to cause chaos for the Black & Gold. The hosts pressed high up the pitch with five players, cutting off the central midfielders and center backs so they could not advance through the middle. For whatever reason, the Crew did not deal well with the press. Typically cool on the ball, the center backs were making bad passes trying to escape pressure which allowed additional chances for Tigres. Another issue was the midfielders’ hesitancy to come back to the ball. Tigres always looked like they were first to react, which spelled doom for Columbus. Tigres’ press aimed to push the Crew back towards their own goal without allowing them to advance the ball to the wings. The hosts left both dropping wingbacks open and tried a pinch press to push the Black & Gold back towards the middle of the field. If Columbus could find the wingbacks or wide players, they could advance the ball much easier around the teeth of the Tigres press. Unfortunately for them, the Mexican side made it tough throughout the first half. Despite the constant press from Tigres, the Crew were able to adjust and find a way to turn the game around in the second half to advance. Another formation change The Black & Gold also tried to tweak their formation from the beginning. In possession, they shifted from their normal 5-2-3 to a 2-3-5. Yevhen Cheberko and Rudy Camacho stayed as the two defenders while Steven Moreira split out on the right as a half-pivot/midfielder. Darlington Nagbe stayed in the center of the pitch as a lone central midfielder while Derrick Jones shifted out to the left as a half-pivot. The attack remained fluid with five players up top. Marino Hinestroza split out to play on the left wing while Yaw Yeboah came inside to play as an extra false nine. Rossi and Cucho Hernandez continued to roam around the center of the pitch with Mo Farsi out on the right wing. This formational switch put emphasis on the attack, committing five players to the front line and giving them freedom to combine. Yeboah was the biggest surprise, pinching inside like a false nine of 10 from his usual wide position. The Tigres press gave the formation problems in the first half, but Columbus learned how to deal with it and find open space in the second half. The Mexican side liked to press the Crew into a certain area of the pitch and try to trap them there, leaving the backside switch wide open. When the Black & Gold realized that if they could switch the ball they could get out of the pressure, they started having more success. Columbus’ goal came on a backside switch to Hernandez who was sitting off the back shoulder of the defender. The Crew changed their formation again after the goal and with some of the substitutes coming on. When Jacen Russell-Rowe came into the game, Hernandez shaded out more on the wing to allow Russell-Rowe that inside space. With Alex Matan coming on for Derrick Jones, the Romanian had to play a bit deeper alongside Nagbe in midfield. These substitutes allowed the Black & Gold to take the emphasis off their defenders to get forward into the attack by bringing on more attack-minded players. The Columbus backline sat back more conservatively after these subs, trying to hold on to the draw while seeing if the offense could combine for the winner. In the end, the Crew battled back from a nightmare first half to advance to the next round thanks to heroics from Shulte and Max Arfsten burying the deciding penalty. The resiliency of this Columbus squad to stick to their game plan and grind out the victory will be one to remember for years to come.

First-year Finley Bizjack entered the transfer portal after completing his first season at Butler. Photo by Jonathan Wang. CALEB DENORME | ASSISTANT SPORTS EDITOR | cdenorme@butler.edu As the men’s basketball season draws to a close, attention shifts to the NCAA transfer portal. Players from around the nation will be on the move in the coming weeks, including those who played last season for Butler. As of right now, Connor Turnbull, DJ Davis, Finley Bizjack and Artemios Gavalas have all announced they have entered the transfer portal. Davis, Jahmyl Telfort and Posh Alexander have all declared for the NBA Draft while maintaining their college eligibility. The transfer portal opened on March 18 and will close on May 1. The NCAA shortened the length of the portal from 60 days in 2023 to 45 days in 2024. Eight of Butler’s 14 players in the 2023-24 season were brought to the Bulldogs via the transfer portal. Davis, a 6’1” guard from California, transferred to Butler from UC Irvine. Davis was third on the Bulldogs in points per game with 13.5 and shot 35.1% from beyond the arc. He ended the season tied for first in the nation in free throw percentage, shooting an impressive 95% from the charity stripe. Davis’ season-high 28 points came in an overtime victory against Villanova. Before Butler, he spent three seasons at UC Irvine where he hit 149 three-pointers and was named to the 2022-23 All-Big West Conference First Team. Alexander, a 6’0” guard from New York, transferred to Butler from St. John’s. Alexander was fourth on the Dawgs in points per game with 11.3 and led the team in steals with 71. Out of the 32 games he played this season, he started all of them. He scored a season-high 21 points on Jan. 16 at Xavier in a losing effort. Before Butler he played three years at St. John’s, winning Big East Freshman of the Year and Big East Co-Defensive Player of the Year in his first season. He also led the Big East in steals per game every season he played for the Red Storm. Telfort, a 6’7” forward from Canada, transferred to Butler from Northeastern. The Canadian was second on the Bulldogs in points per game with 13.9 and led the team in minutes per game with 34.7. Telfort also was second on the team in total rebounds with 126 on the season. His best game came on Feb. 2 at Creighton where he scored 26 points and led the Dawgs to a road win over the Bluejays. Before Butler, Telfort played for three years at Northeastern where he made the Colonial Athletic Association (CAA) All-Rookie team and CAA Third Team. Bizjack, a 6’4” guard, came to Butler from Byron Nelson High School in Trophy Club, Texas. The first-year played in all 33 games, averaging 4.2 points and 1.2 rebounds per game. Bizjack’s best game came on Feb. 13 against Marquette where he scored 19 points in a losing effort. He was named to the Big East All-Freshman team in his first season with the Bulldogs. The Texas native was a four-star recruit and was ranked as the No. 97 player in the class of 2023. Turnbull, a 6’10” forward from Missouri, came to Butler as a four-star recruit in 2022. Turnbull played in 22 games as a first-year, averaging 2.0 points and 5.3 minutes per game. He returned for his sophomore season and appeared in nine games, averaging 4.1 points and 11.7 minutes per game. Turnbull suffered an elbow injury that would hold him out of the rest of the 2023-24 season before entering the portal. Gavalas, a 6’0” guard from New York, transferred to Butler from St. John’s. He played in seven games, totaling eight minutes played on the year. At St. John’s, Gavalas played in seven games in two years, scoring three points in seven minutes of action. None of the players who are transferring have committed to another school yet. All players are eligible to return to Butler if they choose to do so, but all of them coming back is unlikely. The Dawgs have not signed any transfers from the 2024 portal yet. The transfer portal will remain open until May 1 for players to leave or join the Bulldogs.

The Columbus Crew tied an improved DC United side 1-1 on Saturday at Lower.com Field. Cucho Hernandez returned to the lineup after he missed two games due to a “team policy violation”, which caused the rumor mill to circulate among fans. Another player who made their return was Will Sands, starting for the first time since tearing his ACL in 2023. It was a back-and-forth game all night long, with DC generating some good chances and Columbus having some solid spells of possession. United found the breakthrough in the second half courtesy of Christian Benteke. The ball ricocheted off a United player’s back and into the Belgian’s path, allowing him to slot it past Patrick Schulte. The Black & Gold responded though, even after Hernandez earned himself a red card for kicking out at a DC player. Aidan Morris unleashed a thunderbolt from outside the box to square the game. That is how the contest would end, another draw for the Crew. Wilfried Nancy did not change much about his team, but they struggled at times against DC United’s pressure. Let’s dive into the tactics of both sides that influenced this match. Columbus’ strategy The Black & Gold lined up in their usually five/three back formation with two midfielders and three attackers. Yet again though, they would not play the game in a set 5-2-3 or 3-4-3 formation. The Crew shifted to a 3-3-4 when they retained the ball. Wingback Max Arfsten would pinch towards the center of the field to team up with Darlington Nagbe and Morris as midfielders. While he became a midfielder, Arfsten still stayed on the right side of the pitch, acting as a half-pivot for Marino Hinestroza. Morris did the same but on the left side. Sands went high up the pitch as a winger and Morris bridged the gap. This left Nagbe alone to man the center of the pitch with the center backs as support if needed. The outside center backs were more cautious going up the pitch because they had one less midfielder to cover for them. Morris and Arfsten being out wide would have left the Black & Gold in a vulnerable spot if Steven Moreira or Malte Amundsen went forward. So, for now, the outside centerbacks stayed put. Up top, Hernandez and Diego Rossi controlled the two striker positions. They were free to drop in or drift wide if needed. Hinestroza and Sands occupied the outer areas, looking to cut in or whip crosses into dangerous areas. On defense, Columbus continued to play their pressing and re-pressing soccer with some minor changes. Game planning for a striker like Benteke requires special thought, which is exactly what went into Nancy’s plan. The Black & Gold pressed on every United touch, trying to drive them back toward their own goal. This allowed the Crew to re-engage the re-press and turn the ball over higher up the pitch. For Benteke, the same rule applied. Columbus wanted to make him feel uncomfortable with every touch. They knew DC wanted to get him the ball and build their attack around him holding up play, so they had one of the center backs man always marking Benteke. This limited some of United’s attacks, but Benteke still found his goal. In the end, the Crew were fortunate to still get a point after going down to ten men, but they will take it and move forward to Tigres. DC United’s strategy On offense, DC’s entire plan was to play through Benteke. One of the best hold-up strikers in MLS is a nice asset to have up top, especially when you have speed on the wings. United went back to their youth soccer roots, going over and over to a pattern of play that is taught from a young age. The up-back-through technique was perfect for a player like Benteke and for a team that sets up like DC does. United would play the ball into Benteke’s feet, get the ball back to one of the midfielders and then place a pass through to one of the wings. This allowed Benteke to spin off the defender and find space in the box to receive a cross. This strategy was perfect to counter Columbus’ aggressive approach. If the center backs got too overzealous, DC could get in behind with a numbers advantage. This was the case on a few attacks, but heroics from Shulte and other defenders kept the game scoreless until Benteke found the breakthrough in the 61st minute. On defense, United wanted to make the Black & Gold as uncomfortable as possible. The visitors pressed high up the field trying to prey on the Crew’s mistakes. Their plan worked well, it limited Columbus to one goal on the night and it was an unstoppable shot. There was nothing that United could have done to prevent Morris’ screamer. One may argue that the defense could have stepped up sooner, but from that distance, it was implausible for the young midfielder to score such a goal. Despite comprehension, Morris buried the ball in the back of the net, gifting the Black & Gold a point at home. DC played Columbus well, but it will be interesting to see how the Crew responds against Tigres.

The Columbus Crew returned to CONCACAF Champions Cup action Tuesday night, battling Tigres UANL at home. It was an odd night for the Black & Gold, with star striker Cucho Hernandez still barred from the squad in a pivotal game. The match itself was not much better when Tigres opened the scoring in the first 20 minutes. Columbus answered though, courtesy of a Diego Rossi shot that found the far corner. Beyond that, the game was littered with one-sided refereeing decisions going against the Crew. The game flipped when Aidan Morris received a red card for a tackle on a Tigres attacker, leaving the Black & Gold undermanned for the remaining 13 minutes. The Black & Gold rallied though, ending the game in a 1-1 draw. The Crew stayed with their familiar setup but had to adjust to combat Tigres and make up for the absent Hernandez. Let’s dive into all those adjustments. Pinching center backs to overload the midfield Early in the first half, the Black & Gold’s game plan for the centerbacks was clear. Both Steven Moreira and Malte Amundsen had vital roles to play, but not only on defense. With five Tigres players clogging the midfield, Wilfried Nancy shifted Moreira and Amundsen into the midfield on offense. This led the Crew to play in a 1-4-5 formation when they had the ball. It is known that Columbus’ outside center backs are not shy to make runs up into the attack, but this was different. In prior games, both outside backs would aid the attack by overlapping and getting high as additional strikers. In this game though, they were additional help deeper in support. Morris and Darlington Nagbe still played in their usual spots in the middle of the pitch, but they were now flanked by Moreira and Amundsen. One of the attackers, usually Rossi or Jacen Russell-Rowe, would often drop into the midfield to even up the numbers. Not only did this show Nancy’s brashness to send his defenders high, but it also showed his trust in Yevhen Cheberko. With Rudy Camacho out due to injury, Cheberko has become the main man in the middle of the defense. He was sometimes the only one in a deep position to stop a counterattack. When the Crew advanced into the attacking third, the center backs could keep moving higher. Typically, if one center back went to attack the other would stay back with Cheberko. This always gave Columbus two defenders back on defense. It was a small tactical tweak, but it seemed to pay off. The Black & Gold controlled the game for large portions of the match, they just could not find the finishing touch to send Tigres home with a loss Differing wingback positions The Black & Gold lined up in the same formation that has become commonplace under Nancy, a 5-2-3. What shapes that formation takes is a mystery until the whistle is blown to start the game. In the matchup against Tigres, it was the wing backs positioning that changed. The interesting thing is it was different on both sides of the pitch. On the left side, Yaw Yeboah pinched to the inside of the pitch more often than he usually does. At times he would occupy a left attacking midfielder position, or even move into the midfield. The reason for this switch was dependent on who his attacking partner was. In this game, it was Marino Hinestroza. Hinestroza is now well known as a lethal dribbler who can break down defenders with a few flicks of his feet. His abilities in one-on-one situations are mesmerizing, which is why Nancy told Yeboah to cheat towards the inside of the field. Giving Hinestroza as much space to operate as possible will only favor the Crew. If Yeboah were to overlap, he would draw a second defender to Hinestroza and make it harder to get past. So, the Ghanian cheated towards the center of the pitch and acted as a release valve and support for Hinestroza. On the other side it was the opposite case, at least for the first half. The pairing of Rossi and Mo Farsi teamed up in the normal way that Black & Gold fans have grown accustomed to seeing. Rossi came inside and acted as a second striker alongside Russell-Rowe. He had free reign around the pitch, dropping into the midfield or making darting runs in behind the defense. Farsi however, stayed outside of Rossi for much of the first half. He took the winger position and tried to do what Hinestroza was doing on the other side, go one-on-one or link up inside with the other attackers. In the second half, Farsi’s role was tweaked again to give the Black & Gold a more attacking approach. He pinched inside as an extra late-arriving striker while Moreira overlapped on the outside. Again, two centerbacks always stayed back, but Moreira had free reign to fly up the field in pursuit of the second goal. This shift in Columbus’ philosophy showed the team was not afraid to go for the win, even without Hernandez. They will need to bring that energy into the second leg, especially now that Morris will miss out due to suspension.

The Columbus Crew traveled south to take on Nashville SC a week after suffering its first loss of the season against Charlotte FC. Sean Zawadzki opened the scoring for the Black & Gold in the first half with a thundering header off a corner. Nashville struck back, scoring twice in first half stoppage time to grab the lead heading into the intermission. Early in the second half Columbus had a chance to tie the game, but Diego Rossi’s penalty clattered off the woodwork. Marino Hinestroza was the hero to even the score later in the second half, sending a looping header into the side netting. The game ended 2-2, with the Crew taking a point home. With Wilfried Nancy returning to the sideline, the Black & Gold coaching staff returned to full strength. Nancy switched tactics and formations up in the first half but adjusted again in the second half after Nashville’s two goals. Let’s dive into those adjustments. First half setup When the Crew released the starting lineup, there were two irregularities that fans noticed. The first was the absence of star striker Cucho Hernandez. While no real details were provided about his absence other than a “team decision”, he was not available to play against Nashville. The second was the incorporation of three central midfielders, Zawadzki, Aidan Morris, and Darlington Nagbe. Some thought that Zawadzki would play along the backline and Yaw Yeboah would push up into attack like an extra winger. Others thought the same but on the other side with Mo Farsi possibly pushing into the attack as a winger. Both thoughts ended up being wrong though. Columbus’ backline remained the same as always, with Yevhen Cheberko, Malte Amundsen, and Steven Moreira anchoring the center. Farsi and Yeboah remained outside as wingbacks, setting the stage for Nagbe, Morris, and Zawadzki to run the midfield. Both Rossi and Jacen Russell-Rowe stayed high up top as strikers, so the Black & Gold essentially played with three holding midfielders on the pitch. On defense, the Crew set up in a 5-3-2. That formation remained consistent with what Columbus had done in games prior. Offense though was a different story. On the offensive side, the Black & Gold opted to play in a 3-3-4. The three central defenders stayed in their natural positions while the wingbacks pushed high up the field next to Rossi and Russell-Rowe. Nagbe was the conductor in the center of midfield while Zawadzki and Morris had differing roles from their midfield partner. Both Zawadzki and Morris tended to drift outside and act as half-pivots for the wingbacks. They could also be considered as covering wingbacks because they often played defense in the wingback position if there was a turnover and needed to recover. Both midfielders playing as pivots bridged the gap between the wingbacks and outside center backs. The downside was that Nagbe was all alone in the center of the pitch and the wide areas were vulnerable in a counterattack if Morris and Zawadzki did not recover correctly. This formational and tactical tweak worked initially, generating offensive chances and lots of possession. In the long run though, Nashville scored two goals and took a lead into halftime. Second half return to normalcy At halftime, Nancy opted to sub Zawadzki out in favor of Hinestroza. This turned out to not be because of Zawadzki’s play, but because he had suffered a concussion in the first half. Hinestroza for Zawadzki is not a like-for-like switch by any stretch of the imagination. This change put Columbus back in their usual formation, with two central midfielders instead of three. The Black & Gold do not play with a natural no. 10, they often have a fluid front three that is positionless in the final third. Hinestroza slid into that position-less attack alongside Rossi and Russell-Rowe, setting Columbus back in a 5-2-3. With this formation change came a few tactical tweaks. The wingbacks got up the field as usual, but with two midfielders now in the center, the outside center backs were free to push up. Moreira and Amundsen ventured forward much more in the second half with the formation change. The other change was not a concerted tactical change. Columbus struggled in the first half when they tried to go forward too fast and turned the ball over. This gave Nashville more rhythm in the game and allowed them to have more attacking chances. The Black & Gold dominated the second half by controlling the ball, settling down, and keeping possession. By keeping possession, they put constant pressure on Nashville’s defense to remain stout in the face of a potent attacking team. After trying again and again, the Crew finally found the breakthrough courtesy of Hinestroza. Simple reminders to calm down and keep the ball changed the game for Columbus in the second half. The formational changes played their part, but simply reminding an elite team to play their game is powerful. That’s exactly what happened for the Black & Gold, and it allowed them to salvage a point on the road against a stingy Nashville team.

The Columbus Crew dropped its first game of the season in Charlotte FC 2-0 on Saturday night.  Plagued by early injuries and suspect refereeing decisions, the Black & Gold held on to a 0-0 score line until Charlotte broke through in the 83rd minute. The hosts did not let up, doubling their advantage a mere five minutes later to send the Crew home with no points to show for. It was a game of adjustments for the Black & Gold coaching staff, having to weather the storm alone with Wilfried Nancy sidelined in Columbus with an illness. Let’s dive into the tactical adjustments that the coaches put into action down in Charlotte. First half adjustments Just 25 minutes into the match, the Black & Gold already had to substitute Rudy Camacho, Christian Ramirez and had Derrick Jones sent off. Whether the Jones red card is valid or not is up for debate, but the Crew faced the task of playing the next 65 minutes with ten men. This forced Columbus to tweak its formation to compensate for losing Jones in the middle of the pitch. Because Camacho and Ramirez were already subbed off due to injury, the Black & Gold did not have the optimal personnel on the field to play how they wanted. The squad made do with what they had and set up a new offensive and defensive formation. On defense, the Crew only had to tweak its shape slightly. Columbus typically defends in a 5-2-3, so they simply switched to a 5-2-2. They kept the backline intact with the three central defenders and then dropped in Yaw Yeboah and Mo Farsi. Darlington Nagbe and Max Arfsten set up as two holding midfielders with Diego Rossi and Cucho Hernandez in front of them. Arfsten playing out of position was not the coaching staff’s first choice, but they already had to burn two substitutions. If Arfsten could hold down the center of the pitch until changes could be made at halftime, the Black & Gold would be in good shape. Rossi tended to drop deeper to assist the midfield duo, but Hernandez stayed high and roamed that backline as he always does. When Columbus transitioned to offense, they opted to play in a 3-1-4-1. The three centerbacks would stay deep, while Yeboah and Farsi went up and played as wide midfielders. Nagbe stayed as the sole defensive midfielder as Arfsten and Rossi pushed up to play dual no. 10’s. Hernandez stayed as a no. 9 to stretch the defense. Despite being a man down, the Crew still got numbers forward and even scored near the end of the first half. A suspect VAR decision negated that goal, but it showed that even down a man, the Black & Gold can still be dangerous going forward. Second half adjustments Columbus came out of the locker room in the second half ready to make changes. The first change was bringing on Yevhen Cheberko and taking off Yaw Yeboah. This switch allowed the Crew to become more balanced and get certain players back to their natural positions. The central back three changed with the Cheberko substitution and shifted Zawadzki into midfield. Cheberko took his spot at the central center back position, flanked by Malte Amundsen on the left and Steven Moreira on the right. Arfsten went out wide to the left to play left wing-back, while Mo Farsi stayed at his right wingback spot. On defense, Columbus shifted to a 5-3-1. The back five remained with Nagbe, Zawadzki, and Rossi in midfield. Nagbe dropped a little deeper like a no. 6, while Zawadzki and Rossi played like a hybrid no. 8/10. Hernandez continued to probe the defense from his striker position up top. On offense, the Black & Gold changed to a 3-4-2. The three center backs made up the backline, and both wingbacks pushed up into wide midfield roles alongside Zawadzki and Nagbe. Rossi pushed forward and played as a false nine, with Hernandez still in his natural striker role. This setup on both ends of the field gave the Crew a more balanced look and got some players back into their natural positions. There were some caveats to how they played compared to when there is a full complement of 11 players on the pitch. In the second half the Black & Gold tended to sit back a more, likely trying to escape Charlotte with a point. Another tweak was the positioning of Zawadzki and Farsi. Zawadzki tended to push higher up the field to join the attack while Nagbe stayed in his holding midfielder position. Farsi often would pinch towards the inside of the field to help the midfielders build out of the back. This gave Columbus an extra body in the center of the pitch to combine and move the ball. In the end, the Crew conceded two goals in the final few minutes of the match. It was a tough result to swallow with the injuries and refereeing decisions, but it will ultimately be a bump in the road for a team that has high ambitions in 2024.

Senior DJ Davis averaged 13.5 points per game in one season at Butler. Photo by Elle Rotter. CALEB DENORME | ASSISTANT SPORTS EDITOR | cdenorme@butler.edu The men’s basketball team’s season may have ended on the court when they lost to Minnesota in the first round of the National Invitation Tournament, but it continues off the court. Butler senior DJ Davis, sophomore Connor Turnbull and redshirt junior Artemios Gavalas all entered the portal after the season ended. The transfer portal opened on March 18 and will close on May 1. The NCAA shortened the length of the portal from 60 days in 2023, to 45 days in 2024. Eight of Butler’s 14 players in the 2023-24 season were brought to the Bulldogs via the transfer portal. Davis, a 6’1” guard from California, transferred to Butler from UC Irvine. Davis was third on the Bulldogs in points per game with 13.5 and shot 35.1% from beyond the arc. He ended the season tied for first in the nation in free throw percentage, shooting an impressive 95% from the charity stripe. Davis’ season-high 28 points came in an overtime victory against Villanova. Before Butler, he spent three seasons at UC Irvine where he hit 149 three pointers and was named to the 2022-23 All-Big West Conference First Team. Turnbull, a 6’10” forward from Missouri, came to Butler as a four-star recruit in 2022. Turnbull played in 22 games as a first year, averaging 2.0 points and 5.3 minutes per game. He returned for his sophomore season and appeared in nine games, averaging 4.1 points and 11.7 minutes per game. Turnbull suffered an elbow injury that would hold him out of the rest of the 2023-24 season before entering the portal. Gavalas, a 6’0” guard from New York, transferred to Butler from St. John’s. He played in seven games, totaling eight minutes played on the year. At St. John’s, Gavalas played in seven games in two years, scoring three points in seven minutes of action. All three players have not committed to another school yet. They have until the May 1 deadline to transfer to another program, come back to Butler or in Davis’ case, go to the NBA.

Senior Jahmyl Telfort had 25 points in the loss against Minnesota on March 20. Photo by Elle Rotter. CALEB DENORME | ASSISTANT SPORTS EDITOR | cdenorme@butler.edu The men’s basketball team ended their season in brutal fashion on Tuesday night, falling to Minnesota 73-72 in the first round of the National Invitation Tournament (NIT). The Bulldogs had a lead late in the game, but a critical DJ Davis turnover allowed the Golden Gophers to take the lead on two free throws. From there, the Dawgs needed some Hinkle Magic, but the cathedral was fresh out of pixie dust. Jahmyl Telfort led the scoring charge with 25 points, tying Minnesota’s Dawson Garcia. Both Posh Alexander and Davis had 13 points each in the losing effort. Minnesota will move on to face the winner of tomorrow’s Indiana State vs. SMU game. Butler’s once-promising season ended with a 3-7 record in their last 10 games. In a gutting loss, let’s go beyond the box score. Same old situation It’s almost fitting, in a sick way, that Butler’s season ended the way that it did. The game against Minnesota was a microcosm of the entire season in many ways, culminating in the Dawgs’ eventual exit from the NIT. The Bulldogs committed 14 turnovers on the night, some at crucial points in the game. Davis’ turnover with under a minute to go will be the one that sticks out though. All Butler had to do was hold onto the ball, but a lapse of judgment and a poor choice led to Minnesota’s go-ahead free throws. “Their coach was screaming ‘foul,’” Thad Matta said. “I was like ‘keep it DJ, keep it DJ.’” Matta said that he talked with Davis about that last minute turnover, and assured him that was not the only play that lost Butler the game. The Dawgs also struggled to consistently score the basketball. Their track record as a streaky team showed up again, culminating in multiple droughts that lasted for numerous minutes. Those droughts allowed Minnesota to extend their lead, or at times get back in the game. In the end, it was a major factor in the difference of this game. It will go down as a step in the right direction for the Bulldogs in the end, but this loss will leave a bad taste in everyone’s mouths heading into next season. 2023-24 season in review For a team that was only projected to finish above DePaul in the Big East, Butler wildly exceeded expectations. The Bulldogs started the season strong, beating teams such as Texas Tech, Boise State and Marquette. In mid-January there were talks about the Dawgs being an NCAA Tournament-caliber team. Those predictions quickly faded when the Bulldogs ended the regular season on a 3-6 stretch. Despite the shortcomings at the end of the season, Matta still considered this season to be a success. “There’s a lot of factors going into college basketball these days,” Matta said. “We’ve got to keep growing.” Growing is exactly what this team has the potential to do. If all goes according to Matta’s plan, he will have four starters returning next season with the exception of graduate Jalen Thomas. With transfer portal season looming and recruits coming in, this team can only add pieces. All in all, this season will be considered a ‘close, but no cigar’ type of year. They exceeded expectations, got the program on the right track and built a foundation for next season. For Matta though, it is something more. “I told these guys, they gave me life,” Matta said. “I’m real proud of this team.”

The Columbus Crew returned to MLS regular season action with a bang on Saturday, thrashing the New York Red Bulls to the tune of a 3-0 victory. It was a comprehensive and dominating win for the Black & Gold, controlling the game from the opening kick. Cucho Hernandez put Columbus up 1-0 in the first half courtesy of a Yaw Yeboah cross that he rocketed into the roof of the net. In the second half, Jacen Russell-Rowe and Aidan Morris helped secure all three points for the Crew with goals of their own. Wilfried Nancy set up his team as usual, but they shifted to play a different formation for the entire match. Let’s dive into the tactical and formational decisions that went into the Black & Gold’s big win. Playing in a 3-3-4 The Black & Gold lined up in their normal 5-3-2/3-5-2 to start off the game but quickly shifted to a different formation. They changed to a 3-3-4, which sparked an impressive attacking game and a dominant performance for Columbus. New York set up in a 4-4-2 that could shift and change as Emil Forsberg roamed the field. The visitors also like to employ a high gegenpressing system that tends to prey on opposing teams’ mistakes high up the pitch. Although the Crew switched to three in the back on offense, the Red Bulls’ press did not seem to affect them. The Columbus backline consisted of Steven Moreira, Rudy Camacho, and Malte Amundsen still operating in their usual positions. Yeboah pushed high up the field as a left winger to join Hernandez, Russell-Rowe, and Diego Rossi in the attack. Sean Zawadzki pinched inside from his wingback position to join the midfield alongside Morris and Darlington Nagbe. This put the emphasis on the attack for the Black & Gold. With four attackers up top, the Crew stretched New York’s backline and forced their midfielders to help on defense. Spreading the Red Bulls backline led directly to Columbus’ first goal. When Morris shifted out to the left to play as a half-pivot, New York’s right back stepped up to mark him. This allowed Yeboah to get in behind and provide the assist for Hernandez’s goal. Another concern for the Black & Gold was the midfield battle. With four midfielders slated to start on the pitch for New York, the Crew would be outnumbered. With Columbus switching to the 3-3-4, the numbers were still not in their favor. They evened those odds by having the attackers drop in to help build up and around the Red Bulls’ midfield when needed. The Black & Gold did not use the middle of the pitch to build up throughout much of the game though. This meant the midfield battle did not turn out to be as important. With Columbus building up on the wings, they could overload the outsides by shifting midfielders outside. Morris and Zawadzki would move out wide if the ball was on their side of the pitch to play as half-pivots and connect to the wingers. In the 3-3-4, the Crew were able to stifle New York with long spells of possession. Typically, a team like the Red Bulls can win the ball back quickly with their pressing, but Columbus showed their skill by retaining the ball time after time. New York even changed tactics in the second half and started to man-mark the Black & Gold backline. This led the Crew to drop the midfielders inside to help build out, so it did not slow them down much. No matter what New York did, the Crew countered with more possession and attacking chances. It was one of those games where they just could not do any wrong. The shift to the 3-3-4 paid off in a big way, to the tune of three goals and yet another win in this 2024 season. It was a total dismantling of New York by an elite Columbus team that only seems to be getting better. It was only a matter of time until this team caught their stride, and it showed up in the form of a 3-0 win over a talented Red Bulls squad.

The Columbus Crew advanced to the next round of the CONCACAF Champions Cup after defeating the Houston Dynamo 2-1 on aggregate. After winning the first leg 1-0, Columbus returned home and tied Houston 1-1 following a late tally from the Dynamo. Cucho Hernandez opened the scoring in the 40th minute to continue his hot scoring streak. The Black & Gold played well from that point on but conceded a penalty in the 90th minute. Houston would convert, but the Crew ended up seeing the game until the end and advancing. Wilfried Nancy used a rotated lineup yet again, which meant the team set up a little different than usual. Let’s dive into the tactical decisions that helped the Black & Gold advance. Darlington Nagbe playing attacking midfielder Darlington Nagbe’s position is not as much about him, but more about the personnel Nancy put into the starting lineup. Nancy opted to go with three strikers in the starting lineup, with Hernandez, Jacen Russell-Rowe and Christian Ramirez all getting the nod. While Hernandez and Russell-Rowe can regularly drop in and play as a no.10, it is not the optimal position for them. Nancy’s response to this was to push Nagbe forward to play the no. 10 position on offense. Derrick Jones stayed back as the lone defensive midfielder, only sitting a few yards in front of the backline. At times, Hernandez and Russell-Rowe dropped in to help Nagbe build up, but most of the game was played in transition with Nagbe at the attacking midfielder position. Columbus went relatively light in the middle of the pitch, opting to overload to wings. Both Yaw Yeboah and Mo Farsi ran the length of the pitch, getting into the attack as much as possible. Even the outside centerbacks pushed up to form a cupped backline and assist in the attack. The way the Black & Gold can adjust their formation based on personnel and still find ways to grind out games is impressive. Playing in different forms with rotated teams will be key if the Crew are looking to compete in all these different competitions. It has worked so far, but it is still early in the season. Changing formations in-game Just like last week’s matchup against Houston, Columbus played with formational fluidity and changed their shape throughout the match.  Yet again, the Black & Gold changed their look a few times against the Dynamo. The Crew started out in a 5-2-3 on defense and a 3-4-3 on offense. The four midfielders on offense played in a stretched diamond, with Nagbe as the no. 10 and the wingbacks playing wide midfielder positions. The front three consisted of the three strikers, but they are all interchangeable as they roam the field. Later in the match, Columbus switched to a 4-2-4. This time, the entire backline shifted to the right with Farsi going up into the attack to play as a right winger. Russell-Rowe and Ramirez played as dual strikers with Hernandez on the left wing. Nagbe stayed as the no.10, which allowed a deeper Jones to help on the defensive line if needed. This switched happened around the 35-minute mark just as the Black & Gold were pushing for their goal. This change let Farsi commit more to the attack and allowed the Crew to push Steven Moreira and Yeboah into the attack from outside fullback positions. Jones stayed in his deep-lying midfield position to give the defense stability, so Columbus was still balanced in the back. These shifts can turn the tides of matches, which is exactly what happened for the Black & Gold and allowed them to move on in the Champions Cup. With a congested schedule and more games to come look for the Crew to keep changing how they setup and continue to rotate their lineups.